Fear in Trumptopia

I will grant that our forebearers in the Pleistocene Era survived in part because they learned to assume that the rustling in the grass might be caused a snake rather than merely the wind. This default assumption served them well because in their case a “false positive” resulted in no more harm than to stop them in their tracks for a moment while they assessed the situation before moving on.

By the time of Ancient Israel, human consciousness had progressed to the point that, rather than fear the foreigner, the sojourner, and the alien living in their midst, our forebearers learned to set aside their fears and embrace others from outside their tribe. To minimize risk of harm at the hands sojourners, these forebearers of contemporary Judaism, Christianity, and Islam developed an ethic of hospitality; a reciprocal agreement that the traveler would be welcomed, housed, and fed. The traveler agreed not to plunder the household of the host. The host offered hospitality and protection and the sojourner behaved as a gracious guest, shared news from far away, and did not overstay.

We find evidence of this shared agreement throughout the Hebrew Scriptures. Numerous passages declare that the sojourner and the alien must receive just treatment; be allowed to glean the fields and vineyards for sustenance; and participate in festivals and celebrations.

When the prophets spoke out against the injustice of their day, they warned that doom and devastation would come as the consequence of the unjust acts of an unjust society. They repeatedly listed the mistreatment of the sojourner and the alien among the shortcomings that foretold doom.

Now, I am not naïve enough to think that America has no enemies in the world or that there are not people living among us who wish us harm. What I do believe and would ask our leaders to consider is that fear-based policies such as travel bans, extreme vetting, and refusal to admit refugees creates a climate of unwarranted fear and suspicion. Further, that policies that grow out of this fear and suspicion do more to bring about the radicalization of immigrants, inspire homegrown acts of domestic terrorism, and perpetuate unrest than they do to make us secure.

Unlike the rustling in the grass caused by the wind, the “false positive” of assuming that all immigrants, all refugees, and all Muslims pose an imminent threat causes harm to us. It creates an unwarranted climate of fear. It justifies irrational policies like building a border wall, singling out followers of one of the world’s great peace-loving religions, and denying aid and comfort to honest, trustworthy souls who are seeking nothing more than a safe refuge from war, violence, and death.

If we should fear anything in our current circumstances, we should fear the corrosive effects of our fear-based over-reactions and unjust policies. Instead of fearing the immigrant, the refugee, and the sojourner among us, we should fear the hardheartedness that results from exaggerating the threat of international terrorism, homegrown radicalization, and undocumented immigrants living peacefully among us. Instead of walling ourselves off from our neighbors, closing our airports, and attributing hostility to billions of peace-loving Muslims, we must listen to the angels of our better nature, move cautiously yet boldly toward opening our hearts and our borders, and build our national policies on a firm foundation of justice and righteousness rather than upon the sands unwarranted fear and ignorance.


  1. Jim

    That’s a very good no excellent commentary. We have stereotyped the Muslim’s as all bad, but I could say the same for christians and other groups. Reguardless what group your from there are always going to have bad apples and followers. It is those who create fear and disguise themselves in order to do harm. I don’t have any problems with any religions I find it very interesting to learn the history but for the rotten apples how do you separate the good from the bad. There are over 8 billion people on this earth and I could say 98% are good hard working people. That leaves 2% that are that killing someone doesn’t matter to them. I call them cowards they brainwash there followers in doing mass suisides (smart for the coward leaders) that one person can kill a hundred. This is what I believe our new government is trying to do keeping these invisible bad apples at bay. When I lived in Europe I worked with Turkists, India, Iraq people and partied and played gold with many and I never thought anything about it never even crossed my mind that their was Muslim’s hating Americans. The Muslim ‘s that I was around dreamed of becoming an American. There is so much more going on in Europe right now that we don’t even know about it it has only gotten worse in the past 4 years. I can’t help but believe the last administration didn’t have a role in what’s happening in Europe. I don’t want it brought over here even though I’m sure they (the radicals) are already here in place waiting for their orders. I hope this made sense typing on my iPhone I get a head of myself 😊

    • jspain1

      Thanks for your feedback. Your thoughtful comments are a great example of why we as a nation and as individuals in our local settings need to have liberals and conservatives in dialog with each other rather in opposition with each other. In my left-leaning opinions I tend to minimize the dangers in the real world and tend to be overly optimistic about the power of community to engage and transform our potential adversaries into friends and allies. I need to be reminded that there are hard-hearted adversaries out there who will shoot and destroy first and listen and engage later, if at all. Our national policies need to reflect both perspectives. To move too far in either direction has harsh and unintended consequences.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s